MM2 Value Calculator: Trade Checker for Godlies & Chromas

An MM2 value calculator adds up the value of every knife and gun on both sides of a Murder Mystery 2 trade and tells you if you win, lose or trade fair. Add your items, add theirs, and the tool gives the value gap, a demand check and a short list of items that would even the trade out.

Values here were last updated in November 2026. MM2 values move with every event and new crate, so the date on the tool matters when you trade high-tier godlies and chromas.

MM2 Trading Terms You’ll See in the Tool

• Godly: The main high-tier weapon rarity. Most of the trade market is godlies: Harvester, Icebreaker, Gingerscope, Traveler’s Axe, Sugar and many more.
• Ancient: An old, very rare tier made up mostly of event knives. Corrupt, Elderwood Scythe, Batwing, Icewing, Logchopper and Swirly Axe are all Ancients.
• Chroma: A colour-shifting version of a godly. Chroma Fang, Chroma Gingerblade and Chroma Luger are some of the most traded. A chroma is worth far more than its normal version.
• Vintage: Weapons from the earliest days of MM2, such as Shark, Slasher, Saw and Tides. They hold value because no new copies can be unboxed.
• Unique: One-of-a-kind or nearly one-of-a-kind items, like Nik’s Scythe. These rarely trade, so their value is a rough guide at best.
• Demand: How many people want an item right now, out of 10. High demand means you can trade it on fast.
• Overpay / underpay: Paying more or less than list value. Traders often overpay for high-demand items and ask for overpay when giving them away.
• Set: A matching knife and gun released together, like Hallowscythe with Hallowgun. Sets can sell for a little more together.

How to Read Your Trade Result

The verdict uses a 5% band. If the two sides are within 5% of each other, the trade is Fair. Over that, it’s a Win for the side getting more. Past 25%, it’s flagged as a Big Win or Big Loss.

Under the verdict you’ll see:

• The give/get bar. A quick look at how the total value splits between the two sides.
• Demand check. The same trade, weighted by each item’s demand score. Two items with the same value aren’t equal if one has 10/10 demand and the other has 4/10.
• Close matches. When the trade is uneven, the tool lists items worth about the gap. Tap one to add it to the side that needs it.

Press Copy trade link to send the full trade to someone else, or Copy result to paste a short text summary into Discord.

Three Common Trades, Answered

“Is Harvester for Icebreaker a win?”

Harvester is listed at 1,450 with 10/10 demand. Icebreaker is listed at 1,200 with 8/10 demand. Giving Harvester for Icebreaker is a Lose of about 17% for the Harvester owner, and the demand check makes it look worse, because Harvester is the easier item to trade on. If you own the Harvester, ask for an add near 250. The tool suggests items like Elderwood Scythe for that gap.

“Should I trade one big godly for several smaller ones?”

Splitting a Gingerscope (960) into Hallowscythe (380), Watergun (420) and Candy (320) adds up to 1,120. That reads as a Win on paper. But the three smaller items have lower demand, so you’ll need more trades to get back up to a top item. It’s a good move if you want variety. It’s a weaker move if you’re working toward a Corrupt or a chroma.

“Are chromas worth it?”

Chroma Fang (900) is worth roughly 25 regular Fangs (35 each) in this list. Chromas hold their value because they come in tiny numbers, but they’re slower to trade than top godlies. Only take a chroma if you plan to keep it or you know someone who wants it.

Top MM2 Items by Value

The full list, with search, rarity filter and sorting by value or demand, is in the Value List tab. Each row has +Give and +Get buttons so you can build a trade straight from the list.

How MM2 Values Are Decided

There is no official price list in Murder Mystery 2. Values come from the trading community: what items actually swap for, how many copies exist, and how many people are asking for them. Here is what pushes an item up or down.

Supply

Event godlies stop dropping when the event ends. Vintages and Ancients can’t be unboxed anymore at all. Fewer copies plus steady demand means higher value.

Looks and feel

Some knives just look better or have a better throw animation, and players pay for that. Harvester’s high demand comes from how popular it is, not only from how rare it is.

Events and new crates

The Halloween and Christmas events add new godlies every year. Older event items from the same season often get a bump as players hunt for full collections, while brand-new items start high and settle over a few weeks.

Duping and value list changes

If a batch of an item gets duplicated through a bug, its value usually drops once the community finds out. Big value lists change their numbers in response, and the market follows.

How to Avoid Getting Scammed in MM2 Trades

• Check every slot before you accept. Some scammers swap a chroma for its normal version, or a godly for a lookalike, at the last moment.
• Don’t fall for fake value lists. Someone sending you a screenshot of “new values” that happen to favour them is a red flag. Check the item in the calculator yourself.
• No trust trades. Anyone asking you to give first and promising to “send it back” is not going to send it back.
• No item-for-Robux deals. Cross-trading MM2 items for Robux or items in another game breaks Roblox rules and has no protection.
• Ignore links. Trade links that ask you to log in are phishing pages that steal accounts.

Value Units in This Calculator

MM2 value lists used to price items in Seers, the cheapest godly. Most lists have since moved to plain numbers, and different lists use different scales. The numbers in this tool sit on their own single scale, so compare items inside this list, not against numbers from a different site.

Our value lists are set up the same way across games. If you trade pets too, the Adopt Me value calculator covers Neon, Mega and potion versions. If you play UG VR, the UG tier list ranks dinos from S to D tier.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most valuable item in MM2?

Among items that trade regularly in this list, Corrupt (Ancient) has the highest value at 3,600. Nik’s Scythe is listed higher but almost never trades. Among godlies, Harvester leads at 1,450.

Is the MM2 value calculator accurate?

It is as accurate as the values behind it. We build them from current trades and the main community lists, then update after events. Treat the result as a fair baseline, and use demand to decide how much overpay to ask for.

What does WFL mean in MM2?

Win, Fair or Lose. When players post a trade and ask “WFL?”, they want to know which side comes out ahead. The calculator gives that answer based on current values.

Are chromas better than godlies?

A chroma is worth much more than the normal godly of the same name, because far fewer exist. Top godlies like Harvester can still trade faster than many chromas because more players want them.

How many items can I add to each side?

Up to eight item slots per side, and each slot can hold more than one copy with the + button. That covers almost any trade you’ll make in game.

Does this tool work on phones?

Yes. It works in any mobile or desktop browser. On phones, the item search opens as a sheet from the bottom of the screen so you can pick items with one hand.